Receiving a call from the other driver’s insurance company after a car accident can be puzzling and concerning. What are they after?

In short: The other driver’s car insurance company is collecting information to undermine your claim and minimize their own payout.

It’s important to remember that you are not obligated to provide detailed information or recorded statements to the other driver’s insurance company. Their game is to use your own words against you, so always limit the information you share.

Insurance adjusters use intimidation tactics and tricks to get what they want. If you need help with a car accident claim, don’t go it alone. Call the St. Louis personal injury attorneys at Niemeyer, Grebel and Kruse for a free case review today at 314-241-1919.

Understanding the Other Insurance Company’s Motivations

No matter what caused the accident or who was at fault, the other driver’s insurance company’s primary goal is to limit their payout. This means their motives may not align with your best interests. 

When they call, the representative of the other insurance company may appear helpful, even acting like they are on your side.

However, they are just looking for justification to challenge your claim.

The Role of the Insurance Adjuster

Insurance adjusters are representatives of their respective insurance companies. They are tasked with:

  • Investigating the circumstances of an accident

  • Speaking to claimants and witnesses

  • Reviewing medical records

  • Analyzing police reports

  • Determining who was at fault for the crash

Ultimately, their job is to safeguard the insurance company’s financial interests by reducing payouts as much as they are allowed under the law.

Gathering Information to Challenge Your Claim

As we mentioned above, the main reason the insurance insurance adjuster calls is to collect information to fight your claim.

They may appear friendly and supportive, but remember that their primary goal is to protect the insurer’s interests. They might ask seemingly innocent questions about the accident and your injuries, prodding to get you to slip up and reveal evidence that could reduce the payout.

We’re taught to be friendly to people who are friendly to us. It’s nice to be polite.

However, this is a time to be firm and short. 

How to Respond When the Other Driver’s Insurance Company Contacts You

1. Verify the Caller’s Identity

After picking up the phone, the first step is to confirm the caller’s identity and their affiliation with the other driver’s insurance company.

Ask for their full name, position and the name of the insurance company they represent. This ensures that you are speaking to a legitimate representative from the other insurance company.

At this moment, you are free to end the call. You are under no obligation to speak with representatives from the other driver’s car insurance company.

However, if the conversation goes further and the representative asks for more than basic details about the accident like the date, location or time of accident, it’s best to refer them to your own insurance company or the official police report (your choice!).

2. Limit the Information You Share

If you choose to speak to the representative, provide only basic necessary details, such as your name and contact information. Avoid discussing opinions, specifics of the accident or any injuries sustained, as this can harm your claim.

Respond only to the questions asked without offering additional information or explanations.

Do not engage in conjecture; only share information that is factual and confirmed.

3. You Always Have The Right to Remain Silent

Bear in mind, you’re under no obligation to talk to the representative of the other insurance company in the first place.

You have the right to end the conversation at any time and state that any further communication will be through your attorney. This is especially important if discussions go beyond basic facts, as involving your own insurance company or legal representation can protect your interests.

Individuals are not legally obligated to provide a recorded statement to the at-fault driver’s insurance company.

If you’re uncertain about your rights or feel overwhelmed, consider consulting an attorney to handle the claim on your behalf. This ensures that your case is managed professionally and that your rights are protected.

Why It’s Dangerous to Give Recorded Statements

Providing a recorded statement is a major risk when dealing with the other driver’s insurance company, and it’s always best to refuse a statement.

These statements can severely damage your claim, as insurance adjusters scrutinize them for inconsistencies to undermine your case. They might provoke you into making remarks that downplay your injuries or suggest distraction at the time of the accident, for example.

Recorded statements are often compared with police reports and other testimonies to find discrepancies and attack your credibility. In court, a previous recorded statement can be used during cross-examination to focus on any discrepancies and question your reliability.

Silence truly is golden here.

A Quick Settlement Offer Should Make You Suspicious

If they can’t challenge your claim outright, a common strategy among insurance companies is to push for a settlement.

These settlements often come very soon after the accident, when the full extent of your injuries and expenses might not yet be clear. The aim is to close the claim quickly and pay out as little money as possible.

It can be tempting to accept a settlement offer. After all, who doesn’t want to put a car crash behind them and move on with life?

However, when you accept a settlement, that’s it. That’s all the compensation you can recover.

Early settlement offers may not cover all your medical bills, lost wages or ongoing treatment needs. 

How a Personal Injury Lawyer Can Help

A car accident lawyer can secure larger settlements, ensuring victims receive compensation proportional to their injuries and damages.

Attorneys who specialize in accident-related laws handle complex legal processes, communicate with insurance companies and take cases to court if necessary. This allows you to focus on your recovery and getting back to life.

When to Directly Engage with the Other Driver’s Insurer

In certain situations, it might be necessary to engage with the other driver’s insurer.

If the other driver is clearly at fault but is not communicating with their insurance provider, direct engagement can help avoid delays in claim resolution. Another scenario is if the other driver is misrepresenting the facts of the accident.

When deciding to speak directly with the other driver’s insurance, always remember to be cautious about the information you share.

How a Car Accident Attorney Can Help

With extensive experience in handling various claims, a car accident attorney can proficiently manage the negotiation process with insurance companies. Their duties include:

  • Negotiating with insurance companies to secure fair settlements.
  • Managing all communications with the insurance company to protect your interests.
  • Collecting evidence.
  • Advising on handling medical records to prevent disclosures that might compromise your claim.

Hiring an experienced attorney increases the likelihood of receiving a fair settlement offer due to their knowledge and negotiation expertise.

Get Legal Help Today

Having an experienced car accident attorney on your side can significantly impact navigating the claims process and ensuring a fair settlement. If you’ve been involved in a car crash, don’t hesitate to contact Niemeyer, Grebel, and Kruse for the legal help you need to protect your best interests.

Call today at 314-241-1919 to schedule a free consultation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is the other insurance company calling me after an accident?

The other insurance company is likely calling to gather information that can challenge your claim or lead to a quick settlement. Be cautious about the information you provide.

Should I give a recorded statement to the other driver’s insurance company?

No, it is not recommended to give a recorded statement to the other driver’s insurance company, as it can potentially be used against your claim.

What information should I share with the other insurance company?

You should only share basic necessary information such as your name and contact details with the other insurance company. Avoid discussing opinions, specifics of the accident or any injuries sustained.

Can I refuse to speak with the other insurance company?

Yes, you have the right to refuse to speak with the other insurance company and can state that any further communication will be through your attorney.

Free Case Evaluation

    Practice Areas


    $1.8 Billion: Yaz Birth Control MDL

    $1.8 Billion: As National Lead Counsel for the MDL, NGK Law negotiated, coordinated, and administered the national litigation and settlement of the Yaz birth control litigation. This litigation involved women that sustained injuries, including blood clots, pulmonary embolisms, and deep vein thrombosis, as a result of the birth control Yaz.

    $745,000,000.00: Wrongful Death

    Jury verdict: Jury verdict in St. Louis, Missouri against the distributor of Whip-It’s nitrous oxide after a 20 year old passed out after using them and crashed into a building, killing a 25 year old woman.

    $650,000,000.00: Pradaxa MDL

    $650,000,000.00: As National Liaison Counsel for the MDL, NGK Law negotiated, coordinated, and administered the national settlement of the Pradaxa blood thinner litigation. Clients sustained injuries, including internal bleeding, as a result of the dangerous medication.

    $23,071,000.00: Product Liability

    A 9 month old boy suffered a severe traumatic brain injury due to a defective component on a boat.

    Gladys R.
    Kindness, thoughtfulness and patience

    I really appreciated Dave’s kindness and thoughtfulness and especially his patience with me throughout my lawsuit.
    Lou P.
    Helped me through the process

    Initially, I was reluctant to bring a lawsuit. But Dave answered all of my questions and helped me through the process. I really appreciate all he did to get me what I deserved.
    Matthew G.
    I only recommend NGK anytime

    Very responsive and they help you in any way they can. Micheal Kruz has handled many cases for me and he is very professional and will fight for you every time. I only recommend NGK anytime.
    Dianne C.
    Very professional and friendly!

    This group is great! Very professional and friendly! It was a pleasant experience dealing with these folks! Give them a call! If they can’t be of help, they know someone who can! 😊
    Larry S.
    Far exceeded my most optimistic expectations

    Efficient, effective, have to say they far exceeded my most optimistic expectations. You are doing yourself a disservice if you do not use there services!
    John P.
    Excellent law firm

    NGK is an excellent mass tort and personal injury law firm. Highly recommend.
    David F.

    Proficient and stands up to Big Insurance.
    CategoryCivil law

    © 2016 - 2023 NGK LAW FIRM | All Rights Reserved